American Horror Story: Asylum Season 2
While watching I realized this was the season I quit on. Even though this ended up being a very good season. Once you get past the rather ridiculous attempts at Boston accents there are some great themes. There are a plethora of references to dig into; Alien abduction Betty and Barney Hill of NH., they did not use names and set them in MA. but the idea is there and although the abduction opening scene is not the focus it is used in the season with great effect. They also reference asylums in Massachusetts and we had some shit happen in those. I have worked in a couple different former location here in MA when I had a decade long career in mental health. They are often reclaimed properties we used to start new innovative mental health programs. The semi-abandoned grounds of former hospitals are still scattered across the state although they are rotting away in many cases. So seeing urban explorers in relics on the show is common here. AHS showed us the perils and lack of agency of both woman straight and lesbian and the use of mental health to attempt to pacify them (I won't say cure). Hell this season even gave us a Nazi doctor who made his way to America but never gave up his Aryan dream of a super race. The reference to the role of the Catholic Church in turning a blind eye to the Nazis is also clear to see. It has a lot in it and really more than described. The collage of characters approach was really well acted with Sarah Paulson and Jessica Lange killing in this season. My main problem is that they don't necessarily provide catharsis in most of the story lines. There are resolutions but the effects are blunted by usually by characters being so flawed harsh and cruel that you don't care about the character by the time the writers try to redeem them. Sister Judy "Jude" Martin played by Lange is a good example. She is so awful to everyone around her that her back story of a drunken singer who joins a nunnery after hitting a little girl in the road and leaving her. Did she make the choice to have a story arc that can be redeemed by serving other, there is no way you can accept this because her behavior seems more like she was just looking for a place to hide. When we her get her comeuppance by ending up in the same asylum, you might think "Good, got what she deserved" but no by the end of the season there is this whole saving her as a character thing that just does not fit with what we had seen. Saved by the one character you could probably get behind Kit Walker (Evan Peters) who was abducted by aliens, experimented on by a Nazi doctor and mistreated as a supposed murderer, and mental health patient. He at least had a heart and an innocents almost no other character had. What was his fate after being the good guy who took care of others including those who mistreated him? He lost all thse he loved, go cancer and was re-abducted by aliens. The story line is left open, did the Aliens help him or did they jut want to study cancer in humans? We don't know in the end. Sister Mary Eunice McKee (Lily Rabe) is a good character but is possessed by the devil in the second episode and is just a pawn for Satan until her death. Before that happens she commit horrible crimes so never gets redeemed. Finally we have reporter Lana Winters (Sarah Paulson) who although not innocent is a character who wants to expose the crimes of the broken asylum system. She ends up having her lover murdered by and herself raped by a serial killer, Dr. Oliver Thredson [The Bloodyface Killer] and delivers a baby she did not want and ends the season by having to kill him. At the end she is shown as a person who ambition is her main driver.
I still don't understand the mean spiritedness of this show. Good storytelling will give us more than just bad people having consequences for their behavior. Maybe I am missing the point, maybe the writers are saying that there are no good people in the world and we all are going to live lives of mistreatment abuse and death without redemption? Well from here on out if I choose to keep watching everything is new to me. I know the next season is called "Coven" so there is a possibility that it means women in charge. It will be interesting but I am not optimistic that it will portray women with power in a positive light. We shall see.




